10 Myths That Might Be Stopping You from Adopting a Shelter Dog (and Why They’re Not True) | Pupford

Adopting a dog from a shelter can be one of the most rewarding experiences, but many potential adopters hesitate due to common myths surrounding shelter dogs. These misconceptions can prevent dogs from finding their forever homes and deprive families of the joy that comes with rescuing a pet.

In this blog post, we’ll debunk some of the most prevalent shelter dog myths and shine a light on the true reality of shelter dogs.

Myth #1: Shelter Dogs Have Behavioral Problems

One of the biggest myths surrounding shelter dogs is that they all have behavioral issues or are "damaged" in some way. It’s a common assumption that dogs end up in shelters because they were disobedient, aggressive, or untrainable.

The Reality

Many dogs find themselves in shelters due to circumstances beyond their control, not because of behavioral problems. Life changes like financial hardship, family relocation, divorce, or the passing of an owner are some of the most common reasons why perfectly well-behaved dogs are surrendered to shelters.

While some dogs may need a little extra training or attention due to their past experiences, many are already well-mannered and socialized. Plus, with the right approach, even dogs with some behavioral quirks can make excellent pets after some love and patience.

You can find hundreds of training resources to train your shelter pup in Pupford Academy+! 

Myth #2: Shelter Dogs are Always Old

Another pervasive myth is that all shelter dogs are senior dogs. Some people may hesitate to adopt because they assume that older dogs won’t be as energetic or have as many years left to enjoy life with their new family.

The Reality

Shelters are home to dogs of all ages, from puppies to seniors. In fact, many shelters often have a wide range of options, including puppies, young adults, and middle-aged dogs. While senior dogs also deserve loving homes and can be the perfect companion for many adopters, people looking for younger dogs or even puppies can often find them in shelters. By adopting from a shelter, you can choose a dog that matches your lifestyle and energy level, whether that's a rambunctious pup or a calm, seasoned dog.

Learn about the joys of adopting a senior pup!

Myth #3: Shelter Dogs Come with Health Problems

Some adopters worry that shelter dogs are more likely to have health issues. They fear that the dog might require expensive medical care or have chronic conditions that could affect their quality of life.

Related Reading: 13 Common Dog Myths Debunked

The Reality

While it’s true that some dogs in shelters may have health challenges, many shelters provide comprehensive medical care before putting dogs up for adoption. This care often includes vaccinations, spaying or neutering, and treatment for any underlying health conditions.

Many shelters also have veterinary partnerships that help dogs receive the care they need while in their custody. Additionally, reputable shelters will disclose any known health issues to potential adopters.

While adopting a dog always comes with some health considerations, just like purchasing from a breeder, there’s no guarantee that any dog won’t eventually develop health problems. The most important thing is to provide regular veterinary care and a healthy lifestyle.

Related Reading: Ethical Breeding Practices

Myth #4: You Can’t Find Purebred Dogs in Shelters

A popular misconception is that shelters only have mixed-breed dogs, so if someone wants a specific breed, they believe they need to go to a breeder or pet store.

The Reality

Purebred dogs are common in shelters. In fact, studies have shown that as many as 25% of shelter dogs are purebred. Breed-specific rescues also exist, where enthusiasts of particular breeds volunteer to help rehome dogs of that specific breed.

Whether you're looking for a Golden Retriever, Dachshund, German Shepherd, or any other breed, there’s a good chance you’ll be able to find a purebred dog in a shelter or through a breed-specific rescue.

Additionally, adopting a mixed breed can be equally rewarding—mixed breeds often have unique characteristics and may inherit the best qualities of several breeds!

Myth #5: Shelter Dogs Have a Traumatic Past

There’s an assumption that shelter dogs have all been abused or neglected, leading people to believe these dogs will carry emotional scars or be too challenging to rehabilitate.

The Reality

While some dogs in shelters may have experienced hardship, the majority are there for reasons unrelated to trauma. Many dogs are surrendered because of circumstances like moving, financial difficulty, or changes in family structure—not because of abuse.

Even those that have been through tough situations are often remarkably resilient and can become happy, loving pets with the right care and support. Shelters often work with dogs to assess their emotional needs and ensure they’re ready for a new home. Rescue dogs can flourish with a patient and loving owner, just like any dog from a breeder.

Find out why MILLIONS of dogs end up in shelters each year.

Myth #6: It’s Harder to Train Shelter Dogs

Many people believe that shelter dogs will be more difficult to train or might not be able to learn as quickly as a dog from a breeder.

The Reality

Shelter dogs are just as capable of learning new tricks and behaviors as any other dog. In fact, some shelter dogs already come with basic training because they previously lived in homes. If they need further training, shelter dogs respond well to positive reinforcement, consistency, and patience.

Training a dog, whether from a shelter or breeder, requires time and effort, but the rewards are tremendous. In many cases, adopting a slightly older dog can actually be easier than training a puppy, since adult dogs often already have some understanding of basic commands or house rules.

Related Reading: Patience for Your Puppy or Dog

Myth #7: Shelter Dogs Are Not Good with Children or Other Pets

Families with children or other pets often assume that a shelter dog will be difficult to integrate into their home. They worry that the dog might be too unpredictable around kids or other animals.

The Reality

Many shelter dogs are great with children and other pets. Shelters usually evaluate a dog's temperament and behavior, including how they interact with kids and other animals, before placing them for adoption.

Families can often find dogs that are already well-socialized and comfortable around young children and other pets. It’s also important to note that many dogs can be trained to be more comfortable in these environments.

As with any dog, supervision and gradual introductions are key when bringing a new dog into a home with kids or other pets. By working closely with shelter staff and volunteers, you can find the right dog for your family dynamic.

Learn about the impact a dog can have on childhood development!

Myth #8: Shelter Dogs are Unpredictable

Some people worry that shelter dogs come with "baggage" and may exhibit unpredictable behavior in the future, making them wary of adopting.

The Reality

Shelters go to great lengths to evaluate and understand each dog’s temperament and personality before they’re made available for adoption. Many shelters have experienced staff who spend time with the dogs to learn about their behavior, preferences, and any triggers they might have.

This helps ensure that dogs are placed in homes that are a good fit for their needs. If a dog has specific behavioral concerns, the shelter will make potential adopters aware and provide guidance on how to manage and work with the dog. With the right match and a supportive environment, shelter dogs can thrive and become wonderful companions.

Myth #9: Adopting a Dog from a Shelter is Risky

Some potential adopters may worry that bringing home a shelter dog is riskier than buying from a breeder. They might think there are unknowns about the dog’s past or temperament that could cause problems in the future.

The Reality

While any adoption or purchase comes with some degree of uncertainty, shelters provide a wealth of information to help you make an informed decision. Many shelters conduct thorough assessments of each dog’s health, temperament, and behavior. Staff members are typically available to answer any questions you might have and help you choose the right dog for your home and lifestyle.

In many cases, adopting a shelter dog is actually less risky than buying from a breeder, as shelters often perform medical exams, spaying or neutering, and even some training prior to adoption. Breeders, on the other hand, may not always provide the same level of upfront care or insight into a dog’s behavior.

Not ready to make the commitment of adoption? Considering fostering a dog!

Myth #10: Shelters Only Have Large Dogs

Many people believe that shelters are full of large, high-energy dogs that may not be suitable for apartment living or homes with limited space.

The Reality

Shelters have dogs of all shapes and sizes, from tiny Chihuahuas to larger breeds like Labradors. Whether you’re looking for a small dog to cuddle with on the couch or a bigger dog to go on outdoor adventures, there’s likely a shelter dog that fits your preferences. Some shelters also work with foster networks, which allows dogs to stay in homes temporarily, giving them a chance to show their true personality outside of a kennel environment. By communicating with shelter staff and foster families, you can find a dog that’s the perfect size and temperament for your home.

Learn more about Understanding Dog Breeds to help you find the perfect companion for your lifestyle!

Conclusion: Adopt, Don’t Shop

There are so many myths surrounding shelter dogs, but the truth is that these dogs are just as deserving of love, attention, and care as any dog from a breeder. Shelters work hard to ensure that dogs are ready to join their new families, and many dogs thrive in their forever homes once they’re given a chance. By debunking these myths, we hope more people will consider opening their hearts and homes to a shelter dog, giving them the opportunity for a second chance at life.

Adopting from a shelter not only saves a life but also brings immeasurable joy and companionship to you and your family. The next time you think about getting a dog, remember: your perfect companion might just be waiting for you at a local shelter.

Check out all the amazing work done by dog rescue organizations!