Mine or not soft and chewy either very hard I can't pull them apart they're very dry and I can get my dog to eat them it's hard for her to choose them as very disappointed in these they have reached out to talk to me about getting a replacement so that's awesome but I've been really ill and haven't been able to get there that far so I will change this once everything's done but as for now I personally wouldn't buy the soft and chewy apple in Maple Bay can training treats because they are my bag at least very hard